How to fix our universities: turn the clock back four decades
It’s taken 30-plus years but finally our university system is facing an existential threat due to the predictable consequences of vastly expanding tertiary education by, on the one hand, maintaining the “free” element while on the other saddling students with debts that many struggle to pay off or never actually reach the earnings threshold that triggers loan repayments, the inevitable consequence of diluting the system with lower-ability students and courses in, for example, sports and event management, psychology, media studies and the like.
This was all in the name of attainment and social mobility. And to pay for it very sophisticated marketing, extolling not just the cachet of getting a Scottish degree, but also the fantastic lifestyle and night life, was used to lure foreign students, a revenue stream augmented by dabbling in the accommodation industry and siphoning seemingly limitless public funds. And now the gravy train has moved on as our universities’ quality declines.
Scotland needs to get back to where it last was in the 1980s when great public education was rammed into kids; those of true university capability got their place, irrespective of background, funded by the grants where required, augmented by aspirational parents and part-time and summer jobs.
I fervently hope, however, that, to quote a fellow alumnus of the Linlithgow Academy bright council house kid undergraduate factory, the rocks won’t have to melt with the sun before this obvious reset happens.
Allan Sutherland, Stonehaven.
Share on:
Recent Articles
Recent Articles

Nine in 10 international students fear for US visa status
Nine in 10 international students fear for US visa status Just 4% of international students recently surveyed said they felt “very or extremely” safe in the US, as shifting visa

UK: Rule changes could be coming for Master of Research programmes
UK: Rule changes could be coming for Master of Research programmes If there is a lesson that international education stakeholders in the Big Four have learned in the past couple

Global higher education enrolments expected to grow through 2035, but new challenges must be addressed
Global higher education enrolments expected to grow through 2035, but new challenges must be addressed Times Higher Education’s new report, Towards 2035: Projecting the Future of Global Higher Education, predicts that university-level

UK government announces earned settlement consultation
UK government announces earned settlement consultation On 28 November 2025, the government announced a consultation on reform of the earned settlement model in the UK. The consultation, ‘A Fairer Pathway to

The government doesn’t know how many people are overstaying their visas – here’s why
The government doesn’t know how many people are overstaying their visas – here’s why The Home Office’s old method of tracking visa overstayers wasn’t perfect, but now there’s no such

US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry
US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry Tourists from dozens of countries including the UK could be asked to provide a five-year social media history